Increase Textsize Decrease Textsize   Email to a friend

Hospital bullying 'festered'

Margo Zlotkowski

Saturday, November 15, 2008

© The Cairns Post

 

A CONFIDENTIAL report has found a culture of harassment was allowed to "fester" at Cairns Base Hospital to the point that a junior surgeon was forced to take stress leave.

The investigation by the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons into complaints of incompetence against Dr Heng-Chin Chiam cleared the junior consultant surgeon but delivered a damning assessment of some hospital procedures.

The report said the harassment of Dr Chiam was "adversely influencing his ability to mature as a clinician" and the failure of managers to take decisive action allowed the matter to fester.

It also warned of the risk of patient care being jeopardised by the long-term destabilising effect of unresolved issues between the departments of surgery and anaesthesia.

Three weeks after the release of the report, leaked exclusively to The Weekend Post yesterday,… no action has been taken by Queensland Health.

Dr Chiam has been on stress leave since June after the hospital’s Department of Anaesthesia made complaints against him and refused to provide anaesthetists to work with him on elective surgery jobs.

Those complaints, which centred on his handling of two surgical cases, were found by the college to have no substance.

The reviewers said Dr Chiam’s treatment in each case was appropriate and "could not be faulted".

"In summary, Dr Chiam is a cautious but safe surgeon," they wrote.

The hospital’s acting chief executive officer Mary Montgomery told The Weekend Post the public could "be assured that all appropriate action arising from the report will be taken".

The independent audit, undertaken at the request of Queensland Health, was "being reviewed and considered in the context of overall surgical and anaesthetic services" within the district, Ms Montgomery said.

The office of Health Minister Stephen Robertson declined to comment about an internal staff matter.

Opposition health spokesman Mark McArdle said Mr Robertson should have intervened months ago to resolve the stalemate between Cairns surgeons and anaesthetists.

"Enough time has been lost and sick Far North Queenslanders have suffered with the shortage of doctors caused by extended periods of stress leave," Mr McArdle said.

The report found Dr Chiam needed adequate clinic and operating time to develop an elective practice and build up his confidence, after being prevented from doing a backlog of elective surgery in the Surgery Connect program and outreach surgery at Innisfail.

 


Cleared: Cairns Base Hospital junior surgeon Dr Heng-Chin Chiam, who has been on stress leave since June, with his youngest son Justin.


also in
Police have announced that the human remains discovered in a crocodile caught near Cooktown, north of Cairns, are those of missing man, Arthur Booker.

Human remains in croc identified

Queensland Police have announced that the human remains discovered inside a crocodile caught near Cooktown, north of Cairns, are those of missing man Arthur Booker. more

<strong>Crisis hits home:</strong> More than 600 people have lost their jobs in the Far North in the past three months, as the global credit crisis hits.
The job losses have been across a wide range of industries, primarily tourism and construction.

600 jobs lost

MORE than 600 people have lost their jobs in the Far North in the past three months, as the global credit crisis batters the economy. more

Trish Ogden is struggling to come to terms with her loss.

Nothing left but ruins

A TEARY Trish Ogden returned home yesterday hours after a fire engulfed the bush escape she shared with her partner and pets. more

“Marto” Martin, Levy “Blueberry” Miller and Michael “Kiwi” Murray aren’t ashamed to be labelled bogans.

Bogans, please stand up

ARE you a bogan and proud of it? more

Police investigate a fatal traffic accident between a car and semi-trailer on the Bruce Highway yesterday morning that left the north-bound lanes closed for hours.

Death sparks road fix call

A FATAL crash between a car and semi-trailer at a Bruce Highway intersection on Cairns%u2019 southside has prompted residents to call for immediate work to fix the trouble spot. more



Comments

See all comments >>

Comments

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional. Read our publication guidelines.

Submit your feedback here:

Full name: Email address:
Location (optional):
Your comments:
(max 1200 characters)
  Remember my details

(So you don't have to retype your details each time you send feedback.)

 

Email me if my comment is published